Honestly I think games are so lazy at the moment. Truly the only game that has impressed on next gen is GTA V. If you think how much is in that game then others fall way behind imo
Playing games after the last of us was like going back to VHS. Bloodborne really impressed me.. I loved the visuals and artwork and i love the Dark souls series anyway so it was a treat after the relative gaming depression I was in.
Zelda on the snes when i was a young lad. I would have to go with Arkham Asylum as that got me back into gaming. There are quite a few other games that have impressed but these two are the stand out ones for me.
Xenoblade Chronicles for Wi, was amazed at the size and content of the game. Cannot wait for Xenoblade Chronicles X which is apparently five times bigger!!!