View: 64|Reply: 0

An unsuitable adaptation

[Copy link]
3-11-2020 00:32:06 Mobile | Show all posts |Read mode
When I started to read Vikram Seth's monster novel, 'A Suitable Boy', I found it hard going: had Seth really written 1400 pages about the attempts of a young woman to find a husband? But the story inside this framing ultimately expanded into an astonishingly broad, subtle, superbly written and cunningly plotted epic. This television adaptation can't quite bring the Seth's full vision to life, and feels much more like I first feared the book would be: an essentially simple story about finding the right partner. We do still see a lot of India; but at times it feels that it's merely providing background colour, while the characters are simplified and presented straight up as the people you gradually come to know over the book's many chapters. It's always hard judging a new version of something you already love fairly, but I couldn't engage with this series. Read the original instead: it's a literary masterpiece.

score 5/10

paul2001sw-1 25 September 2020

Reprint: https://www.imdb.com/review/rw6122468/
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | register

Points Rules

返回顶部