|
Well said!
That's essentially what I was trying to say above.
You missed pointing out that his analogies are invalid. I agree that cars, shoes and electricity are equal in being products you buy, but one doesn't ask 'when do I get my money back' when buying electricity, either. He's comparing a purely optional extra (ie how you buy your electricity) with a basic (whether to buy shoes or a car).
And have a look at his economics. Let's assume that the £140 saving is per quarter, and that it's equal throughout the year (summer quarters you use less, but the sun's stronger, so it might even out). At an outlay of £3,700, that's a payback in 6.6 years: less than the 10 years he quotes, but not enormously so. Also, without knowing his circumstances, the figures are useless in applying to other households.
Not to mention the fact that 80% of the population don't even have a shed, and that 99% are not qualified by law to do that kind of work. Unless he's a qualified electrician, neither is he. |
|