booyaka
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:01
Nasty - unfortunately bills like this can happen with high powered, high end older cars.
A friend bought a M5 with 89k on the clock (8 years old, one lady owner from new) - within 12 months the gearbox was needing a full replacement at a costs of £6k. Nothing he could do but pay up to get it fixed.
Dave Brand
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:02
I'm puzzled as to why a fault like "stretched" cam chains, which is actually a wear problem & therefore happens gradually over a prolonged period, should cause a sudden failure.
Markee
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:02
I always thought the use of cam chains as opposed to rubber belts was for that exact reason - they don’t stretch (I’m not a mechanic though).
Markee
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:02
Info here might be of use to you:
Jaguar V8 engine questions/concerns - Page 1 - Jaguar - PistonHeads
Might pay you to login (register) with Pistonheads and make contact with the member “Jaguar Steve”, he may be able to advise you.
Crafty
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:02
You've got nothing to lose by trying to get the supplying garage to help cover the cost but I wouldn't rely on it. I also wouldn't repair the car until you either have agreement or otherwise - they may want to look at the car as-is rather than rely on another garage's (somewhat vague) diagnosis. If you go legal you might have to get it inspected by a neutral.
What exactly are they going to do for £5k ? even if they had to remove the engine it sounds expensive to me - if you said £500 in bits (new cam chain, coolant) and £75 an hour labour, thats 60 hours or 8 days... and we're being generous with prices there.
If you said a day to pull the engine, half a day to put a new chain on, then 1.5 days to put it back and get it running again what are the other 5 days for ?
If the chain is replaceable in situ it surely can't be any more than a couple of days.
For reference, a friend currently has a Bentley Continental in bits - someone had the engine out has has set the phasing of cam sensors incorrectly, so he's pulling the engine, correcting the error and putting it back together in a similar time to what I've suggested above.
ukdan
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:03
To make sure the price I was quoted was accurate, I phoned the main jaguar dealership near me for a quote. It was within £100 To the independent garage quote. Parts alone is over £2k. It is engine out, strip down and replace all chains, pulleys and tensioner's. 22 hours Labour.
IronGiant
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:03
If the car has done 94K, doubt you can claim off the garage that sold it if you have no warranty.
ukdan
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:03
I bought it with 94k and currently on around 95.5k so not even done 2k miles yet which to me would suggest the fault was on the car when I bought it. Maybe?
IronGiant
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:03
Almost certainly underlying wear and tear that has been developing for many years.Is it the fault of the seller if it didn't manifest itself for 6 months?
ukdan
Publish time 25-11-2019 00:01:03
That is the question I suppose. Just disappointing that I have spent so much money on a car that I have not used that much and now have to spend a third of the original purchase price to be able to use it again.