View: 63|Reply: 0

Why the extra violence? Why the detective?

[Copy link]

11610K

Threads

12810K

Posts

37310K

Credits

Administrators

Rank: 9Rank: 9Rank: 9

Credits
3732793
2-8-2020 11:04:11 Mobile | Show all posts |Read mode
Hitchcock's version was very stagebound, and, except for the assault on Grace Kelly, practically a drawing room mystery. This one adds two more, including one seemingly necessary to create a closure.

Why does the movie go to the trouble of creating Detective Karamor (David Suchet), the archetypical intrepid investigator, then leave the necessary detective and confrontation work to Emily? His sole function seems to be to let Emily know about the missing key. Even his work with the phone records has holes in it - the police should have been able to trace the call to a cell phone and found some details. Knowing that the call came from an unregistered or falsely registered phone should have raised suspicion about the nature of the attack.

score 6/10

klantry 24 January 2002

Reprint: https://www.imdb.com/review/rw0466523/
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | register

Points Rules

返回顶部