petra-axolotl Publish time 1-4-2021 00:32:02

Disappointing

They got some facts wrong and omitted some others that are really crucial.

Contrary to what a commentator claims, Roman armies were essentially militia instead of professionals until the Marian reforms of 107 BC.

It was unlikely that Hannibal was Afro-looking. Carthago was itself a colony established by the Phoenicians and Hannibal was supposedly descended from Phoenician nobels. He most likely looked like an Arab rather than an African.

The Scipio who fought Hannibal later in Carthago was actually the son of the Scipio who went to Hispania but failed to intercept Hannibal. In the show it was as if these two had been the same guy.

The most important Roman figure during the war against Hannibal was Fabius Maximus. Yet he was not even mentioned once in the whole episode.

Hannibal eventually killed himself because his patron at that time was being forced by Rome to deliver him. In the show it was as if he simply had got tired of life.

The only positive thing is that they usually pronounced Scipio's name in the Latin way, i.e. Skipio instead of Sipio.

score 1/10

petra-axolotl 1 October 2016

Reprint: https://www.imdb.com/review/rw3553925/15077
Pages: [1]
View full version: Disappointing