martyncymro Publish time 20-12-2020 11:33:03

Great show - but do NOT compare it to the BBC version.

Great music, costumes, script and characters. I first watched the BBC series (both of them and then bought the DVDs) and am thoroughly enjoying this US version. Rather than just compare it with the BBC version I believe it best to view it on its own merits. The BBC version is pure class, as are most things containing John Simm. (I strongly recommend 'The Devil's Whore') Do not compare the characters/actors with the BBC version as it is certain to lead to dissatisfaction. The script isn't as subtle as the original, true. John Simm is a better actor than Jason O'Mara, true. However the series is very enjoyable and I may even buy the DVD of this series too. Just sit back and enjoy 50 minutes of good entertainment!

score 10/10

martyncymro 5 February 2009

Reprint: https://www.imdb.com/review/rw2018833/14456
Pages: [1]
View full version: Great show - but do NOT compare it to the BBC version.